Tags
baby, breastfeeding, cry it out, crying, newborn, overtired, sleep
My mum went home yesterday.
Babby decided to give us an easy day by going to sleep relatively easily and at regular intervals throughout the day.
Perfect Husband and I were like “We totally rock.”
Then night happened.
Now, most of his 6-7 hour screaming jags have taken place in daytime, and nightime has actually been fairly regular with wakings every 1.5-3 hours and reasonably prompt sleep after feeding/diaper changes.
Not last night.
Today, my first day home alone with Babby, was mixed success. Morning was awful, afternoon was fine. I finally managed to get him to fall asleep at about 10:30 this morning and collapsed into exhausted sleep until 1:30. So that was good. Then he fed, had a diaper change, went in the Sleepy Wrap while we walked the dog, fussed a bit and then slept in the wrap for an hour and a half. Then he woke up, was fed, went back in the wrap, fussed a bit and fell asleep.
This evening was more difficult. It took us an hour to get him to sleep after his dinner meal.
Now, here’s the thing I’m having a lot of difficulty coming to terms with – he seems to need to cry to sleep, sometimes.
The other night we were taking turns walking the floor with him as he had been alternately crying and feeding and crying WHILE feeding for hours. Perfect Husband was flipping through a book I had picked up at the library, called The Baby Whisperer. Now, I had already discounted this woman earlier in the evening because she talked a lot about how “no baby needs to eat more often than every two hours” and saying that once baby’s needs are met, he should be put down to “foster independence.” Both sounds like total nonsense to me and goes against what the lactation consultants and child psychologists say (babies carried more actually have MORE independence later on in life, because they trust their caretaker etc). So I had given her up as a resource. But then PH said,
“Are his eyes staring as if propped open by toothpicks, not focusing on anything?”
“Yes,” I said, “the dog just sniffed his face and he stared right past him.”
“Is he arching his back when he cries?”
“Yep.”
“Then the book says he’s overtired.”
“He hasn’t slept for five hours. We know he’s overtired! What does it say to do about it?”
The book said to lay the baby the hell down and let him fuss himself to sleep.
“That’s cry-it-out! You can’t do that to a newborn. I won’t do that,” I said angrily.
“No, no, it isn’t cry-it-out. She says to stay with the baby and let him know you are with him, but he needs to sleep and anything we do will just continue to stimulate him.”
So against my better judgement, Babby was laid down in his moses basket, covered snugly, and then rocked and rocked and rocked. And damn it all, it worked. Within ten minutes he had settled down.
“The book says he’ll wake and fuss three times before settling down for good,” said my husband.
And damn it all, that’s just what the baby did.
He slept for nearly four hours.
Early the next morning, the same thing happened – he wouldn’t go down. So Perfect Husband took him from me, laid him in his basket, and sat on the edge of the bed, shushing soothingly, watching him and occasionally holding down his arms when he started to flail wildly (because he flails in his sleep and then hits himself in the face, which wakes him up and makes him cry because all he knows is that someone randomly hit him in the face…), while my baby cried and cried. It was breaking my heart, and I kept wanting to take the baby from the basket, but Perfect Husband reminded me that we had tried that and tried that. It was his turn to try.
It felt like forever, but it wasn’t actually all that long. In half an hour, Babby was out for the count, having had his three drift-offs-then-wake-up-and-fuss episodes.
But I was a mess.
Perfect Husband kissed me and told me he was proud of me.
“I don’t like this. It feels like cry-it-out and he’s just a tiny baby. If we let him cry like this it’ll break his trust in us…” I sniffled.
“You fed him. You changed him. You rocked him. He was still crying. He was crying because he was tired, and we can’t force him to sleep. He needs to learn how to do that himself and we can’t help him. Rocking him and walking with him just seems to overstimulate him. We never left him. We were right there with him, and I even held his hands.”
I knew all of this, and over the last couple of days, PH has been proven right time and time again. He cries… and then he will sleep. I did make PH promise to ignore anything this woman Baby Whisperer says about breastfeeding. I picked up a copy of The Womanly Art of Breastfeeding from the library as well, and that has comforted me, because it specifically mentions a growth-spurt in the second and third week, which explains his constant feeding which has been leading to this overtired issue. The constant feeding does seem to be dying down – and my breasts are fuller than they were so I think he was just working to bring in my milk. It’s just a matter of getting him to go to sleep, the poor little insomniac.
Sometimes I can nurse him to sleep, which is always my first choice, but other times he just pulls away from the breast and squirms and cries and that’s when PH steps in with his shhshing noises and his heavy hands pinning down those flailing arms. A friend of mine even sent me a link indicating that some babies are just like this – they need to have a good cry. And the way he just suddenly goes limp after ten or fifteen minutes of fussing shows that it IS exhaustion – not a matter of him crying himself to sleep. But the waiting through that ten minutes is breaking my heart. At least, today, he fussed in his wrap instead of in his basket, and for some reason that was easier on me. I don’t know why it matters, him crying his heart out in his basket or crying his heart out in a carrier, but I can tolerate the carrier easier.
But that doesn’t help at night, when I have to put him down.
There HAS to be a better way.
Poor kid inherited my insomnia and my webbed toe.
I’m sorry, Babby.
For some babies, this IS the better way. This was how I had to get Isaac sleeping – but I didn’t find out about it until he was nine months old, and I’m here to tell you that after nine months of not more than 90 minutes of sleep at a stretch you WILL be crazy.
I know how hard it is to be with baby all day, and do everything for him, and then have PH come home and be able to put him to sleep. For a mom, letting a baby fuss a bit does not come naturally – but it’s clearly what your little guy needs, and as he gets caught up on his sleep that need to fight it so hard will start to go away a bit.
You probably haven’t had time to read many blogs. So I’ll just quote what sweetsalty kate had to say about parenting this week, and encourage you to put it on a t-shirt:
“Parenthood is pain and sacrifice and the extinction of free time and the postponing of dreams and the scrabbling in the folds of the couch for spare change and sanity, peppered with flashes of pure joy. There’s too much propaganda claiming the opposite. That, mostly, parenthood is pure joy peppered with cluster feeding.
Propaganda is dangerous. It makes us feel like we’re all doing it wrong. Like we’ve been passed over by an absent grace when really, grace is a rare phenomenon. As rare as a full night of sleep.”
You’re doing fine. Hugs.
That is one great quote. Amen to that.
Sailor is still kind of like that. At night she falls asleep fine, but about half of her naps consist of her crying pretty hard for about 15 minutes before she’s out. And it’s always when she’s overtired, when she’s gone too long between naps or had a really short previous one.
It sounds to me like you’re doing great. I’ve found that I have to kind of disconnect myself – rather, DETACH myself – emotionally from her when she’s like that. Otherwise, I feel like she can sense that I’m upset, too, and that doesn’t help. I empathize and rock her and shush her until she’s out. Plus, it helps me keep my sanity. Did that make sense?
Hi IfByYes,
Thank you for sharing your labour stories. I very much enjoyed reading your experience, it helped make me fear it a little less. You and your wonderful perfect husband sound like naturals at parenting. Having a baby that won’t sleep sounds very challenging, and you are both working together beautifully, it seems.
All the best to you both, and I’m sending sleepy vibes to the little man. He is adorable by the way 🙂
Here’s the #1 rule about kids: No matter what the books say, or how your mother remembers doing things, or even your experience with another child, EVERY KID IS DIFFERENT and YOU (both of you, as his parents) know him best and will figure out what works for HIM.
If he needs to fuss and even cry a bit to get some good sleep, then that’s what he needs. As long as you’re not leaving him alone, that is definitely not cry-it-out. Heck, he’s going to cry no matter what from the sounds of it, so what difference does it make where he does that as long as he’s not alone?
Actually, it really sounds like PH is doing the Five S’s that Harvey Karp suggests: the “Swaddling” (“pinning” his arms down) to keep him from flailing and startling himself and to make him feel cozy like in the womb, and the “Swinging” (rocking) to give him comforting motion, which he’s also used to from being in utero. Is PH also “Shushing”? Making some kind of “white noise” can help too. Verbally, or through use of a fan or white noise machine. You could try that, too, if you haven’t already.
When Liam was colicky, we had to wrap him tightly and rock him swiftly (the louder they cry, the more vigorously you rock, and then adjust your rocking accordingly as he quiets down till you can stop), all the while loudly saying “SHHHHH!” forever (again, the louder they cry, the louder you do this till they quiet down). We’d sometimes have to keep it up for hours, but it kept him quiet. What a freaking exhausting time that was! Felt like forever, but it was really only a few weeks and is now a distant memory.
You’ll get there. In the meantime, do what works!
that is a great love photo
and mommy you are doing great
🙂
One of the best things (I think) about parenting is that the way it is now, is not always the way it will be. This too shall pass. Just don’t beat yourself up in the mean time over doing what you have to to get your little one to sleep. He’s still so young and getting used to existing in the world, and breathing air and he hasn’t read *any* parenting books so he doesn’t know what should work on him. You just take it day by day, nap by nap, sleep by sleep and by and by things will get different. You are in the trenches right now, and sleep (yours and his) is key in surviving it. Take a Malcolm X stance on his sleep: By Any Means Necessary. If that means letting him cry for a bit (especially if he’s going to be crying anyway, which it sounds like he is) then that’s what you do. If the sound of his crying while PH puts him down is upsetting you so much (as it is designed to do) maybe go have a shower? Or go for a walk? And you *are* doing a great job, you really, really are. When what you were doing wasn’t working you tried something else, and that is so, so important. Don’t let any one parenting philosophy tell you otherwise.
You know what you’re doing here, don’t you? You’re taking your cues from your baby and what he needs, and not from books or from a pre-determined ideology. I’m amazed that you’re making that transition so quickly – like Hannah, I’m pretty sure I took many months longer to do that.
Since I am not a mother I can’t comment with that kind of wisdom, but it seems to me you are doing what you and baby need- isn’t that ultimately what good parenting is about? This is mostly why I try not to have preconceived notions of how I would be as a parent or judge other people’s parenting (*try*…I’m not saying I don’t, I’m saying I *try not to*), cause I have no clue what kind of a mum I would be, or what kind of a kid and situation I will get thrown into. Anyway, it sounds to me like you are doing great- keep it up! Wish I was closer to help out!
you sound like you’re doing a great job! they break our hearts with their cries, but i think that’s why they make daddies:) they’re a little harder than us… we just want to pick them up and “smother” them with love, and daddy just wants them to get some sleep:)
like has previously been said, just learn YOUR baby, and write your own “manual”… and remember the next one is totally different!! which sucks!
Thanks for the reassurances, everyone!
I’m with you. You’re doing the right thing. One of my children taught me that: I’d rock and swing and sing and shush and pace and… she would keep crying and crying and crying, even though I could see she was exhausted. One day, in total despair, I just put her down, because obviously I wasn’t helping anyone, and because I, too, was utterly exhausted, physically and emotionally … and she sighed a deep sigh, closed her eyes, and slept. It was as if she was saying “Oh, thank god all that’s over. Now I can relax.”
My middle child needed to be allowed to work it out for herself, tears and all — and it took me till she was seven or eight months old to figure that out. Well done that you and PH have sorted it out so much sooner.
And my other child? She fussed when she got tired, was soothed by rocking, and then slept. Easy-peasy. She was my first. Talk about false advertising…
I agree with Bea: you parent by responding to him, by doing what works for him, not by a pre-determined ideology that may or may not fit. Adequate, quality sleep is as important for his good health as good nutrition. Just as you wouldn’t feed your two-year-old nothing but Smarties because broccoli makes him cry, you have to put his need for sleep above your emotional response to the crying.
(FTR: All three of my kids (now a teen and two young adults) are warm, loving, TRUSTING human beings, cryer and non-cryers. He’ll be fine! And so will you.)
Pingback: Installation of program “Babby Sleep” was not successful. (R)etry? « If By Yes