animals, cruelty, cruelty to animals, milo and otis, movies, reviews, videos
So, I was trawling through Netflix on my day off and spotted Milo and Otis.
Remember that film?
Admit it, you think about it every time you see a pug, and you can’t hear one of those names without thinking of the other.
I adored the movie as the kid. It had talking animals and British accents, and who could ask for more?
Plus, I loved that it gave such a… graphic depiction of live mammalian birth.
Nothing like a bit of sex ed in your children’s family viewing.
I’m starting to keep an eye out for movies that would be good for Owl to watch when he’s older, so I pressed play.
Aw, it’s so cute! With the British voices, and little animal antics! How did they get that mother cat to swim after her kitten like that?
After twenty minutes I turned it off because… I was beginning to feel disturbed.
I was in TV commercials and made-for-tv movies as a kid, so I had an enlightened attitude of what goes on behind the making of a movie.
If anyone had pointed to Milo And Otis and asked me “is that real?” when I was small, I wouldn’t have had the problem with that question that many younger children do.
Ironically, that’s probably part of what protected me, although I’m sure the reason that myself and all the other kids sat through this movie so happily was simple lack of reflection.
When I watch the movie now, I realize that it is far too horrifyingly real.
By the time I turned it off, I had watched a cat attack two baby birds, get pinched by a crab and a crayfish, a dog attack a frog, a drowning pug being batted about by a BEAR, and then a crying kitten go OVER A WATERFALL in a box.
And then you start to remember the movie a bit.
Wait, doesn’t this cat later fall off a cliff after being attacked by seagulls?
Doesn’t the bear get re-encountered several times?
You don’t think about it as a kid, even if you’re a kid who has been used in filming and knows how contrived it all is.
Milo and Otis gives you the feel of the camera man just having shot hundreds of hours of footage of pugs and tabbies playing, and then making a movie out of it.
One of the things I really liked about it as a kid was that it featured real animals, doing real animal things.
It isn’t like some of those other kids movies where the mouths are made to move in a creepy way, or the animals are clearly responding to a trainer’s direction off-screen (I was hyper-aware of this sort of thing as a kid, and could tell when they switched animal actors, and was alert to where the trainer must be).
Milo and Otis felt more like a documentary, less contrived…
But when you watch it, you realize – it is contrived in all the wrong ways. Because while, yes, it shows a kitten exploring a farm, that kitten probably did not go over the waterfall as part of its natural explorations. And it certainly didn’t just decide to wander off of a cliff when cameras were positioned just-so.
Nor is it like in Homeward Bound, where you see a close up a of a swimming cat, and then something indistinct going over a waterfall.
Or like in another favourite of mine, a documentary/comedy called Animals Are Beautiful People, which shows encounters between predators and prey… but rarely shows both predator and prey in the same shot, making me realize that they had to simulate a lot of this behavior with sneaky cuts.
That’s an actual cat, going down an actual raging rapids, while crying pathetically.
That’s an actual pug, fighting an actual bear.
And yes, that is an actual cat, shown in heartbreaking slow motion, plummeting into the ocean from a cliff that must be at least 30-50 feet high.
Notice that the cat is backwards, facing the cliff he supposedly jumped off. By which I mean, facing the person who must have hucked him over the side.
So I got on IMDB.
I learned that Milo and Otis was not filmed by Columbia Pictures. It was cut by Columbia Pictures from an artsy Japanese film about a cat’s life and its hardships.
They cut it up, added some new footage, cut out a lot of other footage (like this bizarre scene where Milo and Otis reflect on death), hired Dudley Moore to do a voice over, and then raked in the cash.
There’s no notation from the Humane Society about filming, because it was filmed in Japan.
Japanese Animal Rights groups claim that 20 kittens died in the making of this film, mostly while being tossed off cliffs. But there’s no proof, because obviously the film makers aren’t talking, and there was no animal rights supervisor on set.
This online video review of Milo and Otis has some clips from the Japanese version, though, and they’re pretty distressing.
Here’s the original version of the bear fight:
I won’t even show you the cat-trying-to-escape-the-ocean bit. Watch the linked review above for that.
What really hurts me is that I’m always so careful to stay away from these kinds of films.
Because animals still die in filming of these adorable little children’s flicks.
Ask anyone in Vancouver who knows anyone who was involved in the filming of Snow Buddies, one of the Air Bud direct-to-video barf-fests. Five puppies died in the making of THAT film, though that was due to poor care and disease, not through being tossed off of cliffs.
So, while I would naturally avoid exposing my child to drek like Snow Buddies, I had hoped to show him Milo and Otis. I mean, Dudley Moore does such a brilliant job with the voice over. Remember the goofy fox? Awesomeness.
What do I do, now?
I’ve never seen it, and I turned out OK, with no sense that I’d missed anything in my life. You don’t need to show it to Owl. There are lots of great children’s movies that will make fantastic memories for him without the need to throw cats off cliffs.
Seriously, Japan, WTF??
But otherwise how will he see puppies and kittens being born?? :-p
Have you seen Babe? I love Babe. Pig. Of. Destiny!
Please don’t tell me how many pigs and other critters died in the making of Babe.
I should rewatch Babe. It hit me in the wrong places when it came out because a) moving mouths on real animals is creepy (feel this way about the new Charlotte’s web as well), and b) because I loved The Sheep Pig growing up and some of the choices they made struck me as weird (like the whole verbally abusive border collie husband. He doesn’t exist in the book).
I should give it another chance because I do love Dick King Smith so much, and it’s the only one of his books that made it to movie stardom
Good news! http://www.americanhumanefilmtv.org/archives/movies/mr.php?fid=6850
Oh, boooo. I used to love Milo and Otis, and have kept the DVD as one of my stand-by’s for the daycare, because so sweet! I loved this movie, right until I read this post. Now I feel sort of sick. I guess all this time I thought those scenes were faked somehow. Never occurred to me that was a *real* bear! Nor that the kitten *really* went over the waterfall.
I think it’s the cliff scene that really does it for me. I tell myself “okay, I’m sure that was a tame bear. Maybe the bear and pug are friends. Maybe this is playing.” But I’m sure that cat did not throw itself backwards off of a cliff.
And when he comes out of the water he says “all that just for some lunch?” and I think “all that just for a kid’s movie?”
Never watched it…and after reading this, I don’t plan to. It’s so sad that there are people who will sacrifice lives for entertainment (and money).
Pingback: Wreck It Ralph – Perfectly Built « If By Yes